Rights & Tolerance | January 27, 2005
Posting in "Comments
From Left Field"
"The Scarecrow" *
fellow human beings,
Three score years ago, as the war that almost ended civilization
wound down to an end, the Army of Russia opened the gates to a
place that opened the eyes and the heart of anyone with a shred
of humanity: Auschwitz was liberated.
The ghastly images of the dead and near dead. The stories they
told of more than a million souls oh-so-methodically murdered.
The evil acts of individuals and the equally evil complicity of
countless other individuals, in the name of their state and
race. From that day forward, it became necessary to speak and
think of the unspeakable and the unthinkable, if we beings who
purport to be human wish to save our soul.
"How," many ask, "could people do something so
horrible to other people? To so many other people?" That,
unfortunately, is all too easy to answer: a question for
politicians and engineers, those skilled in manipulating people
I believe the better question is, as it usually is, in affairs
As much as that query skewers the human psyche, people wrestle
with many reasons -- some even squirm around inexcusable
"excuses" -- sociological and psychological. And it
may well be that no species, human or otherwise, may be able to
see itself with enough detached clarity to answer such a
fundamental question about its own nature. But to keep from
going quite mad -- with the nagging fear that we might one day
become the victims of such horrors ourselves or, perhaps worse
yet, the perpetrators of such psychopathy -- all of good
conscience have struggled with the why of it all, in the sixty
years since the barbed-wire gates were flung open.
To me, dear friends, the explanation for such extraordinary evil
is rooted in very ordinary instincts...and, thus, is most
cautionary. People hate others and do them harm -- from the
smallest slight to these most horrific atrocities -- because of selfishness.
I speak not simply of greed -- wanting for myself that which is
not rightly mine (and, indeed, the Nazis and their collaborators
stole untold material goods from their Jewish and other victims)
-- but more generally of the state of mind of an individual (or
state of government of a country) that is hostile or, perhaps
even more damning, indifferent to the fate or welfare of anyone
Serving such selfishness, in the extreme, one is absolutely
intolerant of anyone in any way "different" -- racially, religiously, politically, in any definable way
different -- from one's self. The self is served; all others, be
damned. The "Final Solution", from such a point of
view, is not so much the extermination of those who are
different (although that, of course, "must" be done)
as it is the ultimate preservation -- for now and forever -- of
the self and only the self (or, at most, those most like
And as long as there is ego, there will always be such danger,
of selfishness ad absurdum.
But the remedy is not to swing to the other extreme: Extreme
selflessness is also as dangerous. Indeed, the fascism that
brought Jewry in Europe and civilization in the world to the
brink of extinction could not have existed without the selfless
self-discipline of the masses, at the command of the dictator,
the raving embodiment of the cult of self.
No, the answer, as in most of life, lies in a balance: As the
One I worship once said, "Love thy neighbor as thy
self." (Truth be told, many far wiser than yours truly -- from Christ to Confucius
-- have stated this Golden Rule, in one
form or another, down through the ages)
We can learn from history; we must learn from history.
That is why your humble servant, The Scarecrow, but a phantom
from the time of your Revolution, hath returned in yet another
incarnation, to submit context and lessons from the past as you
consider the serious issues of your day: I appeal to your
intelligence and humanity; I never mean to insult them.
Thank God you live in a far better time than that which gave the
world such places as Auschwitz. But never forget that the embers
of evil that, fanned by fanaticism, grew into the Holocaust will
ever lie smoldering, never quite extinguished, wherever the self
holds others in contempt. Never forget that the perfect grace of
our imperfect race is love.
Your obedient servant,
alter-ego, after the classic 18th Century character created in
the early 20th Century by Russell Thorndike in his Doctor
Syn novels, adapted in various films. No endorsement of my
commentaries by any other individual or company exists or is
Archive of LIBERTY: Rights & Tolerance
| Editor | Values
| Legal | Links